Looking for an engagement ring that breaks from tradition? As more couples opt for gemstone engagement rings that reflect their unique personality and bond, the search for a truly personal symbol of commitment begins. If you’re ready to explore beyond the conventional, dive into our countdown of the five most sought-after gems that are making proposals everywhere more personal and brilliant than ever.
1. The Regal Alternative: Sapphire
When people think of non-diamond engagement rings, the sapphire is often the first alternative that comes to mind—and for good reason. Famously worn by Princess Diana (and now the Duchess of Cambridge), the sapphire has an undeniable air of sophistication and royalty.
Why It Works for Engagement Rings:
- Color & Customization: While the deep royal blue is iconic, sapphires come in nearly every color imaginable, including pink, yellow, teal, and the highly sought-after padparadscha (a pink-orange blend).
- Symbolism: Wisdom, purity, and good fortune. Because it is associated with nobility, it’s often chosen as a gemstone that signifies a serious, lasting commitment.
- Durability: The sapphire is a powerhouse. Ranking at a 9 on the Mohs scale of hardness, it is second only to the diamond (which is a 10). This means it is highly scratch-resistant and perfect for daily wear.
2. The Fire of Passion: Ruby
If you want your ring to symbolize blazing, eternal love, look no further than the ruby. This stunning gemstone is a variety of the mineral corundum, just like the sapphire—meaning it shares the same incredible durability.
Why It Works for Engagement Rings:
- Color & Impact: The vibrant red hue makes an immediate and unforgettable statement. Rubies demand attention and signify deep passion.
- Symbolism: Love, health, and vitality. Historically, rubies were worn as talismans of prosperity and protection.
- Durability: Ranking at a 9 on the Mohs scale, rubies are wonderfully hard and require very little extra coddling in a daily setting.
3. The Ethical Sparkle: Moissanite
Moissanite is not technically a traditional gemstone, but a mineral composed of silicon carbide. It has exploded in popularity because it delivers incredible brilliance and durability at a fraction of the cost of a comparable diamond.
Why It Works for Engagement Rings:
- Brilliance: Moissanite has a higher refractive index than a diamond, meaning it actually exhibits more sparkle and fire. It’s impossible to ignore the light it throws off.
- Sustainability: Nearly all moissanite is lab-created, making it an excellent choice for couples prioritizing ethical and environmental responsibility.
- Durability: At a stellar 9.25 on the Mohs scale, moissanite is tougher than both sapphire and ruby. It’s an ideal choice for the active wearer.
4. The Soft Romantic: Morganite
In recent years, the delicate, blushing hue of morganite has made it a favorite among modern romantics. This pink-peach member of the beryl family (which also includes emerald and aquamarine) offers a beautiful, feminine aesthetic that looks spectacular in rose gold settings.
Why It Works for Engagement Rings:
- Aesthetics: Its soft, sophisticated color is subtle yet beautiful, offering a vintage or heirloom quality. It pairs exceptionally well with diamond halos or accent stones.
- Symbolism: Divine love, compassion, and healing. It is often associated with calmness and emotional balance.
- The Caveat: Morganite is softer than the previous gems, ranking between 7.5 and 8 on the Mohs scale. While still suitable for daily wear, it requires a little more care and attention to protect it from harsh knocks and scratches.
5. The Bold and Earthy: Emerald
Emeralds have captivated civilizations for millennia, known for their deep, verdant green color that symbolizes renewal and growth. If you are looking for a ring with history, drama, and inherent visual depth, the emerald is perfection.
Why It Works for Engagement Rings:
- Color & Meaning: The iconic green symbolizes new beginnings, peace, and fidelity. It stands out dramatically against any skin tone.
- Unique Structure: Most emeralds contain natural internal fractures and inclusions, affectionately called jardin (French for “garden”). These imperfections are often seen as part of the stone’s unique character, though they do impact durability.
- The Caveat: Emeralds sit on the 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale. More importantly, due to those internal inclusions, they can be vulnerable to chipping if struck hard. If choosing an emerald, opt for a highly protective setting, like a bezel or a halo setting, to safeguard its edges.
What Settings Work Best for Gemstone Engagement Rings?
The setting is not just about aesthetics; it is the armor that protects your gemstone. For softer or more inclusion-heavy stones (like emeralds or opals), the right setting is non-negotiable.
Here are the best setting styles for gemstone engagement rings, ranked by their level of protection:
1. The Bezel Setting (Maximum Protection)
In a bezel setting, a thin metal rim completely encircles the gemstone. This is the safest setting for colored stones, especially those prone to chipping or abrasion (like emeralds, opals, or soft amethysts).
- Pros: Securely holds the stone, protects the vulnerable edges (the girdle), and gives the ring a clean, modern aesthetic.
- Cons: Can slightly minimize the amount of light entering the stone, potentially reducing sparkle compared to a prong setting.
2. The Halo Setting (Security and Shine)
A halo setting surrounds the center stone with a ring of smaller accent gems (usually diamonds or moissanite). This metal barrier protects the center stone from knocks and bumps.
- Pros: Provides a visual protective buffer, makes the center gemstone appear much larger, and adds immense brilliance.
- Cons: Requires more meticulous cleaning to keep the small accent stones sparkling.
3. The Six-Prong Setting (The Classic Choice)
While the four-prong setting is common for diamonds, a six-prong setting offers significantly more security for a colored gemstone. If one prong fails, the other five will hold the stone in place.
- Pros: Allows the maximum amount of light to enter the stone, enhancing color and brilliance. Classic appearance.
- Cons: Leaves the edges of the stone more exposed to potential chipping, especially if the stone is softer than a 9 on the Mohs scale.
4. East-West Settings (Protecting Corners)
If you select an elongated shape like an oval, marquise, or pear, setting it horizontally (East-West) can actually make the ring sit flatter and feel less prone to snagging on clothing or getting knocked on surfaces.
Choosing Your Forever Gemstone Engagement Rings
Selecting gemstone engagement rings is a wonderfully intimate process. It requires balancing aesthetic appeal, ethical considerations, and practical durability.
The greatest advantage of choosing gemstone engagement rings is the opportunity for deep personalization. Whether you pick the passionate red of a ruby, the cool sophistication of a blue sapphire, or the dazzling fire of moissanite, the ring you choose should reflect the unique vibrancy of the relationship it symbolizes.
More Jeulia Post:
Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Rings Guide: How Big Is Too Big for Your Proposal?
The Art of Pairing Marquise Engagement Rings & Wedding Bands
When and Where Men Should Wear Their Engagement Rings & Wedding Rings